Family Minister Ursula von der Leyen has announced that Web sites containing child pornography from the net to want to banish. Is the response to which it encounters projects. But with all good intentions: the dissemination of these pages is hardly cope. Experts refer to large technical and legal difficulties.
Many victims of child pornography have only just learned to speak. "It is inconceivable, but the children are in the pictures and movies in the increasingly younger. 80 percent are younger than ten, every third is younger than three years, "said Family Minister Ursula von der Leyen (CDU). The minister wants the dissemination of child pornography is now stronger stem. Internet providers, so-called providers should be forced by law, child porn sites to block. Cites as examples von der Leyen corresponding laws in Sweden, Britain or Italy.
From the Cabinet already Minister received the support of the German Economics Minister Michael Glos (CSU). The wishes examine whether the Telemedia Act must be tightened. Backing also comes from the head of the Federal Crime Office (BKA), Joerg Ziercke. He called in August a law. The BKA had about 1000 child porn sites known. Until the summer of 2009 wants von der Leyen now implement their plan. At the height of the Bundestag could fight the law, the social support seems guaranteed, for many undecided a finales (Unions)-choice argument.
That a German law the dissemination of child pornography can actually fight effectively, but is doubtful. On the one hand, technical concerns, on the other hand, suggests that critics who are already signs of the campaign are expected.
Sun said the children's political spokeswoman of the Greens Bundestag, Ekin Deligöz, the minister only wanted to hide that they are in the fight against the abuse of children had been inactive. Even the coalition partners criticized von der Leyen. "The bill has been thrust simple announcement," said the SPD child protection expert Marlene Rupprecht. The coalition did not even advise. Rupprecht and Deligöz belong to the German delegation at the third World Congress against Sexual Exploitation of Children in the coming week in Rio begins. From the Family Ministry State Secretary Gerd Hoofe takes part, Ursula von der Leyen is not flying to Brazil.
International cooperation is crucial in the fight against Internet crime. Because it helps only if Germany access to child porn sites difficult. The "Hamburger Abendblatt" said the board of the German Internet Economy (Eco) Oliver Suemer: "The perpetrators move to another server, and everything that we can reach is that the child content stored on other servers are available." Proxy main problem Server, a kind of mirror. About the user can search a proxy - usually abroad - and no longer needs the German locked page, but around the mirrored in the Maldives.
Problems with the implementation
Recently, when the German Wikipedia address by a left-wing politician by injunction was blocked, this happened exactly. Wikipedia.de was blocked, the German-language online encyclopedia, but remained on the server in the U.S., the German law cut further away. "If you are interested in child pornography, already operates in the dark. These people are mostly technically advanced than ordinary users, so that they are blocking certain sites around quickly, "says Soeren Siebert, a lawyer for the Internet right from Berlin.
There is another technical problem. On a server run many different sides. He can no longer be controlled, are also of blocking legitimate sites on the victims. In October 2007 obtained a company at Frankfurt am Main, an injunction against the provider Arcor, giving access to porn site YouPorn had to block.
The side are contrary to the provisions of minors. But it was not only YouPorn, but many unbescholtene page is no longer attainable. "The verdict of 8 February 2008 decided the regional court, however, that content provider for Web pages to not be held responsible. That is the current legal situation, which applies to all providers, "says Soeren Siebert.
The Internet industry is not only because of the difficult practicalities of the plan by the Leyens. After the discussion about BKA Act and data retention fears the industry censorship infrastructure. Eco wants as opposed to the Minister on voluntary monitoring and the cooperation of building users. On the side of citizens can internetbeschwerdestelle.de pages with content prohibited reported. Eco-after information was provided by the police as in the first half of 2008 some 250 cases of child pornography forwarded.
Many victims of child pornography have only just learned to speak. "It is inconceivable, but the children are in the pictures and movies in the increasingly younger. 80 percent are younger than ten, every third is younger than three years, "said Family Minister Ursula von der Leyen (CDU). The minister wants the dissemination of child pornography is now stronger stem. Internet providers, so-called providers should be forced by law, child porn sites to block. Cites as examples von der Leyen corresponding laws in Sweden, Britain or Italy.
From the Cabinet already Minister received the support of the German Economics Minister Michael Glos (CSU). The wishes examine whether the Telemedia Act must be tightened. Backing also comes from the head of the Federal Crime Office (BKA), Joerg Ziercke. He called in August a law. The BKA had about 1000 child porn sites known. Until the summer of 2009 wants von der Leyen now implement their plan. At the height of the Bundestag could fight the law, the social support seems guaranteed, for many undecided a finales (Unions)-choice argument.
That a German law the dissemination of child pornography can actually fight effectively, but is doubtful. On the one hand, technical concerns, on the other hand, suggests that critics who are already signs of the campaign are expected.
Sun said the children's political spokeswoman of the Greens Bundestag, Ekin Deligöz, the minister only wanted to hide that they are in the fight against the abuse of children had been inactive. Even the coalition partners criticized von der Leyen. "The bill has been thrust simple announcement," said the SPD child protection expert Marlene Rupprecht. The coalition did not even advise. Rupprecht and Deligöz belong to the German delegation at the third World Congress against Sexual Exploitation of Children in the coming week in Rio begins. From the Family Ministry State Secretary Gerd Hoofe takes part, Ursula von der Leyen is not flying to Brazil.
International cooperation is crucial in the fight against Internet crime. Because it helps only if Germany access to child porn sites difficult. The "Hamburger Abendblatt" said the board of the German Internet Economy (Eco) Oliver Suemer: "The perpetrators move to another server, and everything that we can reach is that the child content stored on other servers are available." Proxy main problem Server, a kind of mirror. About the user can search a proxy - usually abroad - and no longer needs the German locked page, but around the mirrored in the Maldives.
Problems with the implementation
Recently, when the German Wikipedia address by a left-wing politician by injunction was blocked, this happened exactly. Wikipedia.de was blocked, the German-language online encyclopedia, but remained on the server in the U.S., the German law cut further away. "If you are interested in child pornography, already operates in the dark. These people are mostly technically advanced than ordinary users, so that they are blocking certain sites around quickly, "says Soeren Siebert, a lawyer for the Internet right from Berlin.
There is another technical problem. On a server run many different sides. He can no longer be controlled, are also of blocking legitimate sites on the victims. In October 2007 obtained a company at Frankfurt am Main, an injunction against the provider Arcor, giving access to porn site YouPorn had to block.
The side are contrary to the provisions of minors. But it was not only YouPorn, but many unbescholtene page is no longer attainable. "The verdict of 8 February 2008 decided the regional court, however, that content provider for Web pages to not be held responsible. That is the current legal situation, which applies to all providers, "says Soeren Siebert.
The Internet industry is not only because of the difficult practicalities of the plan by the Leyens. After the discussion about BKA Act and data retention fears the industry censorship infrastructure. Eco wants as opposed to the Minister on voluntary monitoring and the cooperation of building users. On the side of citizens can internetbeschwerdestelle.de pages with content prohibited reported. Eco-after information was provided by the police as in the first half of 2008 some 250 cases of child pornography forwarded.
No comments:
Post a Comment